It was fantastic.
True, the Led Zeppelin II vinyl and cool new people probably helped, but the music was what made the night. And I have a feeling that my lack of familiarity with the music was a large part of why.
This isn't the first time this has happened - I hear a band for the first time as an opening act or at a music festival, enjoy them immensely, then buy their album and completely lose what I loved before. I mean, the album is usually alright, but never as good as the show. This was the case with Against Me!, Edward Sharpe and the Magnetic Zeros, Apostle of Hustle, The Bravery, and probably a few more bands that I can't remember right now. It is rare that I'll hear a band for the first time live and enjoy them very much on my iPod. Actually, I think it's only happened once: Reel Big Fish. And the album I got was still a live album.
I think this has to do with something I've been saying about concerts for a while now. There are three components to the quality of a concert: the initial quality of the music, the energy of the band, and the energy of the audience. A great show only forms when all three are combined. 3 Doors Down was a lousy show, not just because it was 3 Doors Down, but because I seemed to be the only one there who wanted to have any fun. The Heavy had good music and an excited crowd, but everyone but the singer looked like they were just on stage because they were getting paid to be. Part of the reason that I practically refuse to see a show in a non-standing room venue is because the third component is largely lost when everyone is just sitting.
Sometimes the quality of the music can even be secondary if the other two parts are strong enough. Father's Day last night was actually some fairly terrible music in my opinion. I would never, ever buy one of their albums. But the show was a complete blast, because everyone there was having a fantastic time. The band interacted with the crowd and had fun, and the mosh pit was one of the best I've ever experienced.
Now, when you only have the CD, you only have one component, and so you inherently focus more on the tiniest flaws in the music. If the crowd is good and the band knows how to perform, the experience as a whole will be strong, even if the music itself isn't that great, not to mention the basic thrill increase of live music compared to studio. The concert atmosphere almost acts as a buffer.
The thing is, no one wants to take a risk and go to a show from someone they've never heard of, even if it could turn out to be better than one they do know. Even with all I've said, I'm guilty of the same. But I think that's because most casual listeners don't pay much attention to the local music scene and they only go to shows of bands they know well. I don't blame people for not wanting to drop $60 on someone that could be lousy. But the Trunk Space show was $5 for 5 bands and an entire night of entertainment. And even though Porches was only mediocre and Treasure Mammal wasn't really my thing, the show was great as a whole. If nothing is good, you only lost $5. That's less than a CD, and, as I've said, could easily be better than one.
So hang out around the Trunk Space sometime. I'll see you there, enjoying someone I've never heard of before.
Have a concert story? Think I'm an idiot? Comment to your heart's content.
